Marnie sits in her parked car with the engine off, feeling anxious. Just fifteen minutes ago, her very satisfied client Jack shook her hand. “I can never repay you for what you did for me.”
She now rehearses a line in the rearview mirror for that same person: Jack, just following up on what you told me. If you ever know someone who needs a lawyer, I’d be grateful for the intro.
She says the line twice to herself, swapping out words and using different inflections. It doesn’t make a difference. She can’t picture herself saying this to Jack.
Then she turns the key and starts to drive away.
Like many other talented lawyers, Marnie just made a common mistake: she decided what the answer would be before she ever asked the question. She also made that judgment call alone, in a car, with zero information.
Think about it like this: When someone you like asks you for a small favor, how often do you say no, especially if you owe them a debt of gratitude?
Answer: Almost never, because refusing feels worse than agreeing.
Researchers have gone so far as to measure this gap. Flynn and Lake’s study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology found that people underestimated, by as much as 50 percent, how likely others were to agree to a direct request for help. The authors pinpointed the reason: the person asking dwells on the cost of saying yes, overlooking the awkwardness of saying no.
Cornell’s Evidence Based Living blog describes a related study in which participants had to find three strangers willing to lend a cell phone. They guessed they would need to approach ten people. In reality, they needed six.
The payoff for getting past such fear is real. According to Harvard Business Review, referred clients tend to go through the sales process faster and exhibit greater loyalty. As the head of the Hartmann Law Firm and the author of the new book, Making It Rain: The Art of Building a Successful Law Practice, I can tell you the skill of asking is entirely learnable.
Here are four ways to start.
1. Ask for Advice First
A Management Science study led by Harvard’s Alison Wood Brooks found people see advice seekers as more competent, especially when the task is challenging and the advisor is viewed as an expert.
Next time, try opening with a question: Who do you think I should be getting to know? When you ask for guidance, the other person feels valued and is more willing to help. But this only works if you truly want the answer!
2. Be Specific
Vague requests tend to produce vague results. Instead of saying something generic like Can you send me anyone who needs a lawyer, try this: If you hear of a small business owner stuck in a partnership dispute, I’d love to help. Now the potential referrer can visualize a real person. People tend to refer what they can picture, making it easier for them to say yes.
3. Drop the Sweetener
Some lawyers think they need to pad their ask with a sweetener such as a gift. But Cornell’s Evidence Based Living blog points to research showing incentives matter less than we might assume.
In fact, people are just as likely to agree to small favors for free.
A sweetener can also degrade what was meant to be a compliment into a transaction. A warm, direct request instead treats the ask for what it is: a vote of confidence in the other person’s judgment.
4. Make the “No” Easy
Now for the important part. The same Cornell blog explains why people so rarely refuse: saying no feels awkward, so they often agree to things they are not comfortable with. That pressure puts a responsibility on you.
Instead, ask for a referral when gratitude is fresh in mind, such as right after you earn a good result for a client. Then offer a polite exit: If now is not the right time, I understand. This works because people refer business to those they trust. It’s hard to evoke such trust when the other person feels cornered.
*****
Let’s return to Marnie, our frustrated lawyer in the parking lot. What if she took her hand off the wheel and walked back inside? Her client Jack, the one who told her he could never repay her, would finally get his chance.
If you were in Marnie’s shoes, that referral might go to you.
But first … you have to ask.
Want to learn more about business development for lawyers? Order my new book. And if you or a loved one are facing criminal charges and desire the best defense possible, please contact me.