Long before AI was around, even before the internet’s debut, a former farm boy from Missouri published a book with implications for today’s lawyers.
The year was 1936 and the title was How to Win Friends and Influence People written by Dale Carnegie. Forty-seven years old at the time, he was a respected public-speaking instructor who taught business-education courses for New Yorkers. But he was by no means a celebrity. That would come with the arrival of his book, one that would go on to be translated into nearly every language on earth, selling millions of copies and changing the face of networking forever.
As the recent author of a book on this very subject, Making It Rain: The Art of Building a Successful Law Practice, I thought it would be helpful to revisit this material some ninety years later.
First, it should be acknowledged that Carnegie’s advice wasn’t directed at lawyers. He was writing more for the traveling salesman, the office clerk, and the ordinary person who wanted to be liked and trusted in business. Though our economy has shifted along with our tech since then, his ideas hold up.
The key thing Carnegie grasped so well can be summed up this way: We don’t like to do business with someone who chest-thumps, telling you how amazing they are. That’s a real turnoff. Instead, we tend to work with people we like, with individuals who make us feel understood and seen.
That distinction matters more than ever in the AI Age now that computers can increasingly do so much of the work that lawyers once performed themselves at an hourly rate.
It helps to think of it this way. When was the last time you hired someone, a plumber, a contractor, or a dentist, based purely on their resume? Chances are you asked a friend and they suggested someone they liked. Carnegie understood this instinct long before the arrival of BNI, Provisors, or many of the networking organizations that exist today.
Now, let’s dispel two misconceptions around networking through the lens of Carnegie, the O.G. networker of them all.
Myth 1: Referrals Are an Old-Fashioned Way to Build Your Practice
Some attorneys mistakenly assume that, in the age of ChatGPT, personal recommendations are a relic. The data points otherwise. FindLaw’s 2024 U.S. Consumer Legal Needs Survey found that referrals from family, friends, or trusted coworkers remain the single most common way people say they found the attorney they actually contacted.
Similarly, Nielsen’s global trust research backs this up on a much wider scale: 88 percent of consumers say they trust a recommendation from someone they know over any other form of marketing, outranking every paid channel by a wide margin. And McKinsey’s research on consumer decision-making found that word of mouth is the primary factor behind 20 to 50 percent of all purchasing decisions, with its influence growing strongest exactly when a decision is unfamiliar or expensive.
Yes, technology has changed how referrals show up. Unlike Carnegie’s era, you might get a text or email, but the same mechanism remains intact: one person is vouching for another. This hasn’t shifted in ninety years.
Myth 2: Warmth Is a Soft Skill That Doesn’t Matter in a Serious Profession
Lawyers love to believe gravitas wins the day. Carnegie would have told you that’s backwards. Harvard Business School’s Amy Cuddy has spent years studying how people form judgments of one another.
Her research in Connect, Then Lead is unambiguous. We often size up warmth before we ever do competence. Translation: you could be a brilliant lawyer on par with Clarence Darrow but if you come across as cold and aloof, your business development pipeline will invariably suffer.
As the head of the Hartmann Law Firm and a rainmaker myself, I can tell you nearly every meaningful referral relationship I’ve established traces back to some small, human moment, not a line on a résumé. It comes down to making real, interpersonal connections, the kind Carnegie discusses in his book.
What This Means for You
Carnegie’s message is deceptively simple. Distilled to its essence, he encourages professionals to put others first as a way to cultivate friendships that lead to trust and, eventually, business. We lawyers have a habit of overthinking things. But it doesn’t have to be complicated.
Starting today, you can apply his principles to enhance your profitability. Here’s a small example that can pay off big. The next time you’re at a bar association mixer or grabbing coffee with a colleague, put the phone down and actually listen. Learn what the person across from you is working on. Discover what matters to them. Remember it. And then, consciously seek out ways to be of service.
That’s how you win friends and influence people. It’s also how you can grow your business in a meaningful and lasting way.
If these principles resonate with you, you can find more of them in my book. And if you or a loved one are facing criminal charges and desire the best defense possible, please contact me.